Ball and Chain **Update**

The price on this property is now under $6,000,000. The owner is asking $1,000,000 less than what was paid.

Real estate is notoriously illiquid. When you want to sell it, there is not always a buyer there to unchain it from your ankle.

Today’s featured property is looking at a potential million dollar loss.

29 Blue Grass inside

Asking Price: $6,495,000

Address: 29 Blue Grass, Irvine, CA 92603

Ball and Chain — Social Distortion

Times are hard getting harder
I’m born to lose and destined to fail

Real estate is illiquid. Perhaps you have heard that term before. One of the main criticisms of owning real estate as an asset class is its lack of liquidity, but what does that really mean? Liquidity is the ability to sell an asset and convert it to cash. In case you haven’t noticed, right now, real estate is not very liquid.

Liquidity risk is one of those esoteric and academic concerns that does not apply to the real world–or so people thought during the bubble. When prices were rallying, real estate was very liquid. If you would have put a property for sale in 2004, you would have obtained multiple bids over the ask within days. Real estate was nearly as liquid as stocks during that time. Like every other condition during a financial mania, people assumed this would also go on forever.

{book4}

When stock prices crash, there is still liquidity. You may have to discount the price a few pennies to find a bidder, but there is always a bidder willing to pay something close to the most recent transaction price. In real estate, this is not the case. When a credit crunch causes a drastic reduction in potential buyer’s ability to make bids, offer prices can drop very quickly while the asking prices of sellers do not. This increasing bid/ask spread is one of the telltale signs of a real estate market price collapse.

We joke about the phenomena here. We remark on the denial and delusion of sellers and their WTF asking prices. We see the collapse of demand caused by restricting credit; sellers do not. For instance, look at these two Woodbridge properties: 79 Lakeview Irvine,
CA 92604, Price:
$590,000
; and 24 Lakeview Irvine,
CA 92604
, Price:
$699,000
. The less expensive property is asking $289/SF while the more expensive one is dreaming $421/SF. The former owner accepts reality; the latter owner does not.

The illiquidity of real estate makes property a ball-and-chain. The owners are looking for relief, but they are not going to find any.

Take away, take away
Take away this ball and chain
Well I’m lonely and I’m tired
And I can’t take any more pain

Today’s featured property is a high-end ball-and-chain. It is only being discounted 7% off its peak purchase price. That doesn’t sound like much, but 7% of this purchase price is $500,000!

29 Blue Grass inside

Asking Price: $6,495,000IrvineRenter

Income Requirement: You’re not financing this one.

Downpayment Needed: You are probably paying cash.

Monthly Equity Burn: More than you can imagine.

Purchase Price: $7,000,000

Purchase Date: 8/2/2006

Address: 29 Blue Grass, Irvine, CA 92603

Beds: 6
Baths: 9
Sq. Ft.: 7,600
$/Sq. Ft.: $855
Lot Size: 0.5

Acres

Property Type: Single Family Residence
Style: Santa Barbara
Year Built: 2006
Stories: 3+
View: Canyon, Golf Course, Panoramic
Area: Turtle Rock
County: Orange
MLS#: U9000309
Source: SoCalMLS
Status: Active
On Redfin: 47 days

Gourmet Kitchen Award

Ambiance of a Santa Barbara Spanish home, & casual, resort-style
grounds modeled after those of timeless Montecito estates. Lovely rooms
featuring high ceilings & adorned in luxury finishes from Richard
Marshall hardwood flooring to Venetian plaster, Walker Zanger stone and
tile and custom window treatments. Home features an eminently livable
5-6 bedroom, 7.5 bath floorplan, with one bedroom currently used as an
office and another in a private casita with kitchenette. Every room
features peaceful vistas of the Shady Canyon Golf Course, hills,
canyons, or the beautiful gardens. Main level master suite with
fireplace, private terrace, stunning bath & dual dressing rooms; as
well as living & dining rooms, wine room; gourmet kitchen;
subterranean level with 4-car parking, fitness room, bonus playroom.
Gorgeous landscaping with olive trees & succulents, a shimmering
pool & spa, numerous terraces/covered loggias, BBQ area & 2
outdoor fireplaces.

Either John McMonigle is a good writer, or he hires one. That description describes the property well, it uses a few well-placed modifiers, the grammar and spelling are correct, and most importantly, it did not pain me to read it. I guess when you list a $6.5 million property, you get quality description copy.

This property was purchased for $7,000,000 on 8/2/2006. The owner used a $5,600,000 first mortgage and a $1,400,000 downpayment. Can you imagine the payments on a $5,600,000 loan? Wow! Despite the huge financing amount, this owner must have some real money. He refinanced on 2/7/2007 for $4,900,000. To do that, he had to pay down the original note by $700,000. It is still a huge loan, but a distressed homeowner doesn’t have $700,000 sitting around to pay down mortgages. This guy does.

If this property sells for its purchase price, and if a 6% commission is paid (John McMonigle would make $389,700), the total loss on the property would be $894,700.

It is difficult to project what will happen to properties like this one. Properties over $2,000,000 historically have not been financed (although the bubble changed that somewhat). The cash market for these very high-end properties cannot be valued by a rental income based approach. People with that much money are not using financing, and rental parity is not a concern to them. If you are rich enough to pay cash for a property like this, you buy it because you want it.

The very rich that buy properties like this are still subject to changes in wealth and income like the rest of us. Many of these people are suffering from drops in the stock markets and other asset class valuations. This may or may not cause them to sell real estate. During our last real estate recession, high-end properties like these got hammered. They might get pummeled again.

{book3}

Well it’s been ten years and a thousand tears
And look at the mess I’m in
A broken nose and a broken heart,
An empty bottle of gin
Well I sit and I pray
In my broken down Chevrolet
While I’m singin’ to myself
There’s got to be another way

[Chorus:]
Take away, take away
Take away this ball and chain
Well I’m lonely and I’m tired
And I can’t take any more pain
Take away, take away
Never to return again
Take away, take away
Take away
Take away this ball and chain

Well I’ll pass the bar on the way
To my dingy hotel room
I spent all my money
I’ve been drinkin’ since half past noon
Well I’ll wake there in the mornin’
Or maybe in the county jail
Times are hard getting harder
I’m born to lose and destined to fail

Ball and Chain — Social Distortion

1000 Words, Streamwood, Northwood, Irvine

Sometimes listing pictures are really awful. At least today’s property wasn’t touted as being “light and bright.”

25 Streamwood inside

Asking Price: $137,900

Address: 25 Streamwood, Irvine, CA 92620

{book2}

One house where lovers dwell
Three little kids for flavor
Stir carefully through the days
See how the flavor stays
These are the dreams you will savor

Memories Are Made Of This — Dean Martin

I am always surprised by the low quality of many listing photos on the MLS. In many instances these pictures are so bad that no picture at all would be better. What is the point of putting up a picture that reveals nothing about a property?

Occasionally these pictures are atrocious in an attractive way. We have a thread in our forums devoted to Funky Listing Photos. Let’s take a look at what our members have found:

Sometimes the listing agents want to enhance their pictures with a little photoshop work.

Isn’t the oil painting effect picturesque?

Sometimes the listing agent can’t be bothered to get out of their car and photograph the property.

Perhaps they are worried about running into a meth lab or crackhouse.

Some places are just dirty and need to be cleaned.

Some are downright crappy. Can someone tell me what that board is doing in the toilet?

It isn’t only the people who have bathroom problems.

Some animals are in better shape than their owners.

And some have more taste.

Pink is the new black.

Dean Martin is the man.

It is possible to over stage a property. Am I buying the dishes too?

The pictures of today’s featured property has a unique artistic effect. Perhaps an artist will want to buy this dungeon property for a studio? Perhaps not.

25 Streamwood inside

Asking Price: $137,900

Income Requirement: $34,475

Downpayment Needed: $27,580

Purchase Price: $253,000

Purchase Date: 4/5/2006

Address: 25 Streamwood, Irvine, CA 92620

Beds: 1
Baths: 1
Sq. Ft.: 475
$/Sq. Ft.: $290
Lot Size:
Property Type: Condominium
Style: Contemporary
Stories: 1
Floor: 1
Year Built: 1977
Community: Northwood
County: Orange
MLS#: U9001577
Source: SoCalMLS
Status: Active
On Redfin: 71 days

Lender owned. Quiet,Serene location for this studio unit in the Springs
complex.Lots of trees and overlooks stream. Extra storage. Close to
shopping and freeways.

Quiet,Serene… yes, the tranquility is everywhere… Particularly since this is almost half off its 2006 purchase price.

This property was purchased at the peak for $253,000. The owner used a $202,400 Option ARM first mortgage and a $51,600 downpayment. He did open a HELOC for $28,900 a year later, so he may have pulled out his downpayment. In either case, he lose whatever he put into the property, and now his credit is trashed.

If this property sells for its current asking price, and if a 6% commission is paid, the total loss on the property will be $123,374.

This propperty is being offered for 46% off its peak purchase price.

I hope you have enjoyed this week at the Irvine Housing Blog. Be sure
to come back next week as we
continue chronicling ‘the seventh circle of real estate hell.’ Have a great weekend.

🙂

The Rally is Dead, Lockford, Northpark, Irvine

Rising interest rates will be the end of our Spring rally. Transaction volumes will fall first, and prices will fall later.

157 Lockford kitchen

Asking Price: $399,000

Address: 157 Lockford, Irvine, CA 92602

I’m sitting over Neptune City
I used to love it
It used to be pretty
I’ll come down, walk around a while
Until I’m sure I can never go home again

Neptune City — Nicole Atkins

Prices have stabilized locally through a combination of very low interest rates and very high downpaments. Downpayment amounts have been steadily declining as those few with substantial downpayments have spent themselves. Now, the other component of the purchase price is under tremendous pressure; rising interest rates is reducing loan amounts.

When interest rates go up and incomes do not — a condition we are witnessing now — the amounts people can borrow declines. In the short term it means many deals that went into escrow assuming the borrower could get a 4.5% rate are going to fall out of escrow. The cumulative impact of all these deals falling out of escrow over the next 30 to 60 days is going to be a drop in transaction volumes. By August, this will translate into lower prices as people bidding on properties must adjust their offers to the new level of financing.

It looks as if 4.5% interest rates are gone for good. So what does that mean for future home values?

The brief stabilization we have been experiencing was caused by
interest rates under 5%, and large downpayments. Now that most of the
knife catchers have burned up their downpayment money and interest
rates are approaching 6%, 15% of the buying power in the market just
evaporated. As interest rates keep climbing, buying power keeps
diminishing. This will lead to even lower transaction volumes and lower
prices.

Unless interest rates start dropping again — which doesn’t seem likely — the Spring rally the market has been enjoying is dead.

It should not be surprising that the rally isn’t sustained. There is no way our housing market or the local economy is at a
bottom. Californians have borrowed too much money, far more than their incomes can support. As long as this debt exists, house prices will continue to
decline, and the economy will suffer.

Think about it, if 20%-30% of the population has more debt than they
can service—which they do thanks to liar loans and unstable loan programs—these debt levels must be decreased to
serviceable levels. Reducing these debt levels requires a sale,
foreclosure or bankruptcy. To complete a sale, someone who can afford
the debt must buy a house from someone who cannot afford the debt.
There are only so many of these people out there who are able and
willing to do this. The rest—all the rest—will go through foreclosure.

There are many who believe that loan modifications are the answer. I have expressed my doubts about principal reductions being part of these modifications (see No Forgiveness). Any loan modifications that do occur will simply restructure debt to the maximum serviceable payment level. This will drain all disposable income from borrowers and wipe out our local economy–unless you believe appreciation and mortgage equity withdrawal are coming back soon.

To the extent that loan modifications succeed, our local economy
will suffer. Imagine an economy where everyone is has received loan
modifications. They are all trapped in their homes because they have no
equity, and they are making the maximum possible loan payment their
overlords believe is possible. How is that any different than serfdom?
In such an economy, there would be little or no discretionary spending
to support local businesses because every available penny will be going
toward debt service.

Many individual homeowners are praying for loan modifications that are not going to happen. It is a classic example of being careful what you wish for because if everyone were to get a modification, it would be a disaster.

157 Lockford kitchen

Asking Price: $399,000

Income Requirement: $99,750

Downpayment Needed: $79,800

Purchase Price: $645,000

Purchase Date: 1/26/2007

Address: 157 Lockford, Irvine, CA 92602

Beds: 2
Baths: 2
Sq. Ft.: 1,496
$/Sq. Ft.: $267
Lot Size:
Property Type: Condominium
Style: Other
Stories: 3+
Floor: 1
View: Peek-A-Boo
Year Built: 2002
Community: Northpark
County: Orange
MLS#: S577596
Source: SoCalMLS
Status: Active
On Redfin: 2 days

Prime end unit with elegant 20 ft ceiling entry, hardwood floor and
open floorplan. Kitchen with granite counters and Beechwood cabinetry,
deep cast iron sink, convection oven/microwave.

Somebody paid $645,000 for a two bedroom condo. Unreal.

It didn’t take long for this woman to lose everything. The property was purchased on 1/26/2007 for $645,000. The owner used a $516,000, a $129,000 HELOC, and a $0 downpayment (it is possible she put $129,000 down and was pre-approved for a HELOC).

If this property sells for its teaser asking price and a 6% commission is paid, the total loss on the property will be $269,940. This property is being offered for 38% off its peak purchase price.

Look What Happens When Inventory is Low, Inglenook, Northpark, Irvine

Any increase in pricing brings delusional sellers out of hiding. They put their properties on the market at WTF price levels and hope to hit the lottery.

12 Inglenook kitchen

Asking Price: $1,149,000

Address: 12 Inglenook, Irvine, CA 92602

{book6}

Every time I try to walk away
Something makes me turn around and stay
And I can’t tell you why

I Can’t Tell You Why — The Eagles

Most people watched prices go up in California during the Great Housing Bubble and they had no idea how and why it happened; most didn’t care, they just enjoyed feeling rich. The only explanation most people could come up with is that California real estate is “different.” We are running out of land, you know.

The higher up the property ladder you go, the stronger the belief in price-drop immunity becomes. The people who bought $1,000,000+ homes are under the impression that buyers might be a bit scarce right now, but that their homes have still been increasing in value by 10% or more per year.

They are in for a rude awakening.

Once there is the slightest sign of life in this price range, all the overextended borrowers and those discretionary sellers looking to cash in their lottery tickets put their houses for sale. This adds to the already bloated inventory of homes priced to sit at the high end. These properties will sit on the market until the owners tire of the listing, or in many cases succumb to their debts and end up in foreclosure.

I have made some bold predictions on this blog and many people did not believe possible when I made them. I have said a number of times that the high end is going to crash very hard — in some places 65% or more (particularly near the beach). I stand behind that prediction. It isn’t a matter of “if” it is just a matter of “when.” (BTW, I am not alone in this prediction.)

12 Inglenook kitchen

Asking Price: $1,149,000

Income Requirement: $287,250

Downpayment Needed: $229,800

Purchase Price: $1,024,500

Purchase Date: 5/24/2006

Address: 12 Inglenook, Irvine, CA 92602

Beds: 4
Baths: 3
Sq. Ft.: 2,400
$/Sq. Ft.: $479
Lot Size: 4,277

Sq. Ft.

Property Type: Single Family Residence
Style: Tuscan
Stories: 2
Year Built: 2006
Community: Northpark
County: Orange
MLS#: U9002694
Source: SoCalMLS
Status: Active
On Redfin: 2 days

HIGHLY DESIREABLE NORTHPARK SQUARE FOUR BEDROOM, THREE BATHROOM HOME.
THIS GREAT HOME HAS A PERFECT FLOORPLAN. OPEN KITCHEN WITH ALL THE TOP
OF THE LINE FEATURES, INCLUDING A CENTER ISLAND WITH BAR
SEATING,GORGEOUS QUARTZ COUNTERTOPS,FULL TILE BACKSPLASH AND BUILTIN
DESK WORK STATION. 20 INCH TRAVERTINE STYLE DESIGNER FLOORING,BEAUTIFUL
BERBER CARPET AND PLANTATION SHUTTERS. THERE IS A MAIN FLOOR BEDROOM
AND BATH. THE UPSTAIRS INCLUDES THE ADDITIONAL BEDROOMS AND
BATH,LAUNDRY ROOM, LOFT,BALCONY, WONDERFUL MASTER BEDROOM AND BATH,
WITH LARGE SOAKING TUB AND WALKIN CLOSET. THIS IS A WONDERFUL FAMILY
HOME IN A PRESTIOUS COMMUNITY WITH RESORT STYLE AMENITIES, THAT
INCLUDE,POOL,SPA, SPORT COURT,PARKS AND GAZEBOS. ALL IN AN OUTSTANDING
BECKMAN HIGH SCHOOL NEIGHBORHOOD.

ALL CAP

DESIREABLE? PRESTIOUS? WALKIN? BUILTIN?

This property was purchased near the peak on 5/24/2006 for $1,024,500. It is difficult to check comps because “No similar recent past sales could be found.” The owners have a $960,000 first mortgage on the property, and there is a $25,000 HELOC. Realistically, these people are already $100,000 or more underwater, but if someone is willing to relieve them of their debt burden, it looks like they are willing to move out.

35 Canyon Ter front 35 Canyon Ter kitchen

Asking Price: $2,490,000

Income Requirement: $622,500

Downpayment Needed: $498,000

Purchase Price: $1,782,500

Purchase Date: 1/13/2006

Address: 35 Canyon Terrace, Irvine, CA 92603

Beds: 4
Baths: 5
Sq. Ft.: 3,500
$/Sq. Ft.: $711
Lot Size: 10,293

Sq. Ft.

Property Type: Single Family Residence
Style: Mediterranean
Stories: 2
View: City Lights, City, Mountain, Panoramic, Has View
Year Built: 2005
Community: Turtle Ridge
County: Orange
MLS#: P690058
Source: SoCalMLS
Status: Active
On Redfin: 8 days

SPECTACULAR VIEW!! Preimium Pie Shape lot brings city, canyon, mountain
and snow view in winter. Each room has views.Most beautiful Estate in
desirable gated community.* Crown molding, built-in
entertainment,closet organizer, custom tile in all baths, suround
speaker system, Gourmet Kitchen, stainless steel appliance, trough sink
with swain neck stainless faucet, central vacumn system, Upgraded can
lights t/o house, Plantation wood shutters, Distressed hardwood floor,
BBQ, fountain, fireplace in courtyard, BRING YOUR GUEST-CASITA in
private location, professional landscaping with custom painting.
**Master suite has balcony with gorgeous view and open space.

Preimium? suround?
vacumn?

Most beautiful Estate? I find this kind of BS particularly annoying. First, this isn’t an estate, it is a tract home, and second, are you sure it is the most beautiful?

35 Canyon Ter front

Like many owners in Turtle Ridge, these people believe their properties are “special.” They also bought at the peak, but since their property is so beautiful, it has appreciated $750,000 since they bought it.

WTF

WTF?

Based on neighborhood comps, they might be able to get out at breakeven if they wanted to sell today, but that would not give them the huge profit they are due.

One of the great features of the IHB is going to be seeing these WTF asking prices years from now. When properties like these are back under $1,000,000, these $2,500,000 asking prices are going to be a hilarious testament to just how crazy the housing bubble was.

The Crooked House, Del Italia, Westpark, Irvine

There was a crooked man and he walked a crooked mile,
He found a crooked sixpence upon a crooked stile.
He bought a crooked cat, which caught a crooked mouse.
And they all lived together in a little crooked house

4 Del Italia kitchen

Asking Price: $679,900

Address: 4 Del Italia, Irvine, CA 92614

Follow her down to a bridge by a fountain,
Where rocking horse people eat marshmallow pies.
Everyone smiles as you drift past the flowers,
That grow so incredibly high.

Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds — The Beatles

I saw a story on MSN recently that the inspiration for John Lennon’s song was gravely ill. Of course, most people believe the Beatles were writing about drug induced hallucinations, but wherever the song came from, it is etched in the minds of our collective consciousness.

So where do crooked little houses on crooked little lots come from? Are the planners and designers high? In land planning, there is a tradeoff between the width of a lot (which translates into development costs) and the attractiveness of the street scene. Narrow lots are most cost effective, but they make for garage-dominated elevations and an unattractive street appearance.

Alley-loaded products are one possible solution, but the additional alleys eliminate back yards and drive up development costs. Many different solutions have been implemented to improve the street appearance while keeping lots narrow and cost effective. One such attempt at innovation is represented by the angled lots of the neighborhood where today’s featured property is located.

When you drive down the streets in these neighborhoods, on one side you will see garage doors, but on the other side, you will see the side of the garage that has often been dressed up with windows or other architectural features. Since the house fronts are at an angle to the street, the lines along the front elevations are broken, and the street takes on a more varied and attractive appearance.

Unfortunately, this kind of neighborhood is a nightmare for planners and surveyors because the lot lines have so many corners and crooked lines (A typical lot is a rectangle with four straight lines). Compare a normal rectangular lot to the lot outlined in red above. These neighborhoods are also difficult to build because the moving lot lines creates confusion on the construction site. The architecture has to be tailored to the lot as well.

It you drive around this neighborhood (or look at Google Street View), you can see the results of what the land planners intended. Some may consider it successful, and others may not. Developers for the most part are not impressed with the concept as evidenced by the fact you no longer see subdivisions designed in this way.

{book7}

As if on cue, the realtor has managed to take a series of crooked photographs to go with this crooked house on its crooked lot. Perhaps these fish-eye lenses are not a panacea for interior photography.

4 Del Italia inside 4 Del Italia kitchen

Asking Price: $679,900

Income Requirement: $169,975

Downpayment Needed: $135,980

Purchase Price: $327,000

Purchase Date: 5/31/2000

Address: 4 Del Italia, Irvine, CA 92614

Beds: 3
Baths: 3
Sq. Ft.: 1,430
$/Sq. Ft.: $475
Lot Size: 5,138

Sq. Ft.

Property Type: Single Family Residence
Style: Mediterranean
Stories: 2
Year Built: 1987
Community: Westpark
County: Orange
MLS#: S577287
Source: SoCalMLS
Status: Active
On Redfin: 4 days

Quiet & private cul-de-sac location. Highly upgraded with wood
floors, French doors, plantation shutters throughout, vaulted ceilings
recessed lighting, huge private yard with gazebo, state of the art fire
and burglar alarm system, built in wall to wall garage cabinets,
breakfast nook, newer appliances, newer paint. Beautiful association
parks, pools and tennis courts. Close to great schools, shopping,
entertainment and more!

This property was purchased on 5/31/2000 for $327,000. These owners have paid down their mortgage since purchasing, and the current debt is only $250,000! Perhaps you think I am crazy for making a big deal of this, but it is so rare, that I have to celebrate it when I see it.

If this property sells for its current asking price, the owners stand to make a fortune. At $475/SF, I don’t give it much chance, but at least with some IHB exposure, people will know it is there.