The Rich Feel They Missed Out on the Recession

Nothing serious today. Sometimes Fridays are just for fun….

Irvine Home Address … 208 GUINEVERE Irvine, CA 92620

Resale Home Price …… $469,000

Oh, poor twisted me

Oh, poor twisted me

I feast on sympathy

I chew on suffer

I chew on agony

Swallow whole the pain

Oh, it's too good to be

That all this misery

Is just for, oh, poor twisted me

Poor twisted me

Metallica — Poor Twisted Me

Rich Guy Feeling Left Out Of Recession

April 1, 2010

WILTON, CT—Michael Chandler looks out the windows of his sun room, past the swimming pool and guest cottage, to the wide backyard where his two children are playing with their pet dalmatian, Scotty. At a time when Americans everywhere are sharing the struggle of a once-in-a-generation recession, Chandler can't help but wonder how he and his family fell through the cracks.

"It's just not fair," said the 49-year-old real estate developer and grandson of oil baron Duncan Chandler. "Everyone is worrying about an uncertain future and coming together to express their outrage, and I don't get to be a part of it."

Staring out at the ornate garden where workers were installing a large marble fountain, Chandler sighed and added, "It's like I don't even exist."

According to the multimillionaire, the past 18 months have been incredibly difficult to endure, as he is often left feeling excluded from an American populace that includes millions who struggle every day to make ends meet. Chandler, who watched helplessly as his enormous fortune easily withstood the market freefall, has been "completely left out" of one of this nation's most significant cultural moments.

"Everybody's suffering," Chandler said. "And here I am, not scrimping and saving at all, with no demoralizing periods of financial hardship, or frantic weeks living paycheck to paycheck. What about me, you know? Where's my struggle?"

"Everyone's supposed to get a fair shake at this misery," Chandler added. "Even incredibly wealthy people of privilege like me."

Throughout the economic downturn, Chandler has tried to tap into the recession and experience some of the sorrow and widespread desperation he has so cruelly been denied. Sadly, all of his attempts have been thwarted by his seemingly insurmountable stack of riches.

According to longtime financial adviser Ben Schultz, Chandler "constantly" inquires as to whether any of his diversely invested mutual funds are losing money, but is always let down.

"Michael's portfolio is better than ever, to be honest," Schultz told reporters. "In fact, his only real connection to the recession is that he helped to cause it by artificially inflating home prices and making millions off unstable derivatives trading."

Chandler has been so devastated by his inability to feel the same anguish and hopelessness the rest of the country is enduring that he took the extraordinary step last week of speaking openly with a chauffeur about how hard the recession has been on everyone. He even went so far as to tip the driver 50 percent less than usual in an attempt to show the man that he, too, was hurting financially.

"I kept waiting for him to say, 'Well, times are tough on all of us,' or 'Who isn't feeling the pinch these days, eh?'" Chandler said. "But he just seemed really angry."

Despite his best efforts, Chandler told reporters he knows that someday the crisis uniting so many of his fellow Americans will pass, and that the far-reaching anger will give way to the worship of money that preceded it.

But until then, he admitted, it will hurt to be excluded.

"Every month they announce tens of thousands of layoffs," Chandler said, "and every time, I'm not one of them. No matter what I say or do, it'll never be me. My only memory of this historic point in time will be the prosperity I have always known."

Added Chandler, "Dear God, when's this recession going to end?"

The difference a HELOC makes

Do you remember the chart of the options the lender and the borrower have in a delinquency?

HELOCs can be either a purchase money or a non-purchase money loan. For it to be a purchase money loan, it must be originated and fully used to purchase the property. The HELOC retains its non-recourse status up until the day the borrower first uses it for any purpose other than the purchase of the property. For instance, if a borrower uses a $132,216 HELOC to purchase a property (as today's featured owner did), and he borrowed all $132,216 to buy the property (no way to know on my end), the loan is non recourse. However, as time goes by and the borrower pays down the loan, there is equity available for the borrower to extract. The moment they do, all non-recourse protections are lost.

This issue becomes very important to today's featured property owner. It determines whether or not he walks away with no further responsibility to the lender for the debt, or if he falls down to the last three options on the chart — none of which are very appealing. The property was purchased for $661,500 on 12/22/2005. The owner used a $528,864 first mortgage, a $132,216 HELOC, and a $420 down payment.

In either case, the sale of this property is going to ruin this guy's credit, but whether or not he used that HELOC determines if he only loses $420 or $132,216. That is quite a difference.

Irvine Home Address … 208 GUINEVERE Irvine, CA 92620

Resale Home Price … $469,000

Home Purchase Price … $661,500

Home Purchase Date …. 12/22/2005

Net Gain (Loss) ………. $(220,640)

Percent Change ………. -33.4%

Annual Appreciation … -6.8%

Cost of Ownership

————————————————-

$469,000 ………. Asking Price

$16,415 ………. 3.5% Down FHA Financing

4.25% …………… Mortgage Interest Rate

$452,585 ………. 30-Year Mortgage

$88,992 ………. Income Requirement

$2,226 ………. Monthly Mortgage Payment

$406 ………. Property Tax

$300 ………. Special Taxes and Levies (Mello Roos)

$39 ………. Homeowners Insurance

$300 ………. Homeowners Association Fees

============================================

$3,272 ………. Monthly Cash Outlays

-$352 ………. Tax Savings (% of Interest and Property Tax)

-$624 ………. Equity Hidden in Payment

$25 ………. Lost Income to Down Payment (net of taxes)

$59 ………. Maintenance and Replacement Reserves

============================================

$2,381 ………. Monthly Cost of Ownership

Cash Acquisition Demands

——————————————————————————

$4,690 ………. Furnishing and Move In @1%

$4,690 ………. Closing Costs @1%

$4,526 ………… Interest Points @1% of Loan

$16,415 ………. Down Payment

============================================

$30,321 ………. Total Cash Costs

$36,400 ………… Emergency Cash Reserves

============================================

$66,721 ………. Total Savings Needed

Property Details for 208 GUINEVERE Irvine, CA 92620

——————————————————————————

Beds: 3

Baths: 2 full 1 part baths

Home size: 1,950 sq ft

($241 / sq ft)

Lot Size: n/a

Year Built: 2006

Days on Market: 164

Listing Updated: 40449

MLS Number: S616084

Property Type: Condominium, Residential

Community: Woodbury

Tract: Wdgp

——————————————————————————

According to the listing agent, this listing may be a pre-foreclosure or short sale.

This is a three bedroom townhome style open floorplan that is perfect for entertaining. Bring your must discerning buyer and notice all the fine detail in the finely open gourmet kitchen. could have a main floor bedroom or office. Woodbury is one of the nations finest communties with a walk to destination mall amenties to fit any five star accomodations and the finest schools. Come see this gem. Model perfect.

communties? amenties? accomodations?

I hope you have enjoyed this week, and thank you for reading the Irvine Housing Blog: astutely observing the Irvine home market and combating California Kool-Aid since 2006.

Have a great weekend,

Irvine Renter

19 thoughts on “The Rich Feel They Missed Out on the Recession

  1. Planet Reality

    I’m glad you are speaking out on this very serious topic. I too feel segregated from the recession. It’s not hip any more to be in the top tax bracket receiving double digit % raises and large bonuses. Too much media attention is focused on option ARM debtors, dealing with their unlawful foreclosures. What about the new Irvine home owners settling into neighborhoods with $150K median incomes? Why is it shameful to watch the Irvine school system increase it’s test scores while most southern California school systems face layoffs, budget cuts, and recessionary plight? Why must we feel like we need to quit our high paying jobs, burn our prominent degrees, donate our assets, and move to Las Vegas to belong?

    1. DarthFerret

      Please point out these $150K homes in Irvine.

      TIA,
      -Darth

      P.S. If that’s the median, are half of them below $150K? Please link to those also. Thanks.

      1. winstongator

        He’s talking about incomes, not home prices…150k income at today’s rates, 25% DTI -> 600k home prices.

        Even areas where median incomes are $150k can experience price pressures. Imagine the stock of homes doubles, or people start moving away. Ten families w/150k incomes chasing 10 homes is a much different market than those ten families ‘chasing’ twenty homes.

    2. AZDavidPhx

      PR – Congratulations on all of your success. You should tell us more about what it is that you do. Where did you go to school? What degree did you get? When did you make your first million? Give Joe Lunchbox an idea of what it takes to become so successful. I want to be just like you and emulate you in every way when I grow up. Please share your story, I bet IrvineRenter would even be willing to dedicate a weekend open thread to your amazing and highly inspirational story.

    3. Kyle

      I hope you’re being tongue-and-cheek. If not, you’re more insufferable than I’d originally assumed.

    1. Geotpf

      Yup-click on the link (or just hover over it). Even before I did that, I could tell-they have a very identifiable “house style” to their goofiness.

  2. Perspective

    Is your flow-chart for California property? If so, maybe there should be two options below Lender Recourse Options: “Non-Judicial Foreclosure” and “Judicial Foreclosure.”

    In the Non-Judicial Foreclosure box (nearly all foreclosures pursued in CA), you’d include “Charge-off Debt as Non-Collectable. Issue 1099*.” (You can add an asterisk to this to explain that discharged debt related to primary occupancy property is temporarily excluded from IRS & FTB income tax through 2012).

    Under the Judicial Foreclosure box, you would include the three options you already have listed:
    Seek Deficiency Judgment,
    Become Unsecured Creditor,
    Charge-off Debt as Collectible. Issue 1099.

  3. lowrydr310

    Hey! Now’s the time to invest in Las Vegas real estate.

    With rising unemployment now at a record 15%, rents have nowhere to go but UP!

    In all seriousness and in defense of any Las Vegas RE investors, the article does mention some positive news:

    “A number of economic indicators important to Nevada’s fortunes have been showing signs of life in recent months,” he said. “At the national level, personal income has improved, increasing nearly every month this year. Even in Nevada, incomes have seen growth. The question is: When and by how much will income growth translate into improvements in Nevada’s tourism-based economy? That translation has a lot to do with consumers’ willingness and ability to pay for a trip to Nevada. While it’s still early, we may be seeing some tentative signs of improvement.”

    Visitation to Las Vegas has increased nearly every month in the last year, and both taxable sales and gaming win recorded big year-over-year gains in recent months, Anderson pointed out. One month of positive movement doesn’t make a trend, he acknowledged, but he added that those key statistics are at least heading in the right direction.

    I wonder if this is a real improvement, or if is the squatters stimulus at work?

  4. winstongator

    Hot Property

    If you had the money and wanted this, you should not consider buying, but instead lease it. @2.2M, 25% down, 6.5%, even with deducting interest, you’re at nearly $11k/mo cost of ownership. Take out the tax break (likely given what your income would be and with the AMT), and you’re at $13.6k/mo…more than 2X the $5900/mo listed.

  5. JDSoCal

    “Bring your must discerning buyer”?

    WTF? Is that a buyer who is very picky about his must? I think it needs a hyphen.

Comments are closed.