The Perfect Storm Hits the Housing Market

Oct 21st, 2010  
by IrvineRenter  in Library News

Astute Observations

Astute Observation by awgee
2010-10-21 06:31 AM

Sales in Riverside declined 23.7% yoy.  Prices will soon follow.  Ouch!

Astute Observation by Nick
2010-10-23 06:01 PM

The correction can be stretched out, but the severity of the drop will remain the same as reversion to the mean is inevitable.  That includes another 20% drop in home prices nationwide.  And a 20-30% further drop in Orange County, depending on the area and home type.

http://www.zerohedge.com/article/gary-shilling-why-underwater-homeowners-will-double-23-40-shortly

$300 per sq. foot is still far above the mean.

Astute Observation by winstongator
2010-10-21 06:34 AM

The other thing impacting how prices have changed recently in one city vs another is how far they fell.  Sure San Diego is up 9% from this point 2009, but it is still 34% off peak, while Charlotte, while down 3% from 2009, is only down 14% from peak.  Note how they put Tampa with Charlotte - Tampa is down 42% from peak.

Also, the ability for foreclosures coming on the market to cause price declines is dependent on the foreclosure rate in an area, which is very geographically dependent.  New foreclosure actions in CA are 1/178 units, while in NC it is only 1/984.  This points to continued declines in the bubble regions.

This is also a problem because every state has similar legal throughput capability for foreclosures, so the high foreclosure areas are swamped, and were also the areas with the weakest underwriting, either related to capacity to pay or collateral.

Astute Observation by lowrydr310
2010-10-21 06:55 AM

START TO LIVE THE ORANGE COUNTY LIFESTYLE TODAY

Which part of the OC lifestyle, the $3,052 Monthly payment (for a 2BR)?

WHY ARE YOU SHOUTING AT ME?

Astute Observation by gepetoh
2010-10-21 02:07 PM

They’re not shouting, they’re just super enthusiastic about the house.  Like those Car salesmen on TV on Sunday mornings.

Astute Observation by jimmyJ
2010-10-21 07:56 AM

They aint making anymore land!!!!!!!!

Buy NOW, and get priced IN FOREVER.


I cant phathom how many marriages/relationships have been totally destroyed (or in the process of being destroyed) over this housing mess…

Astute Observation by Jiji
2010-10-21 08:43 AM

Everyone working needs to get a 50% raise, and the Gov can’t figure out how to do it.

That’s where we are.

The real truth.

Astute Observation by Anonymous
2010-10-21 09:21 AM

Re: “The Gov can’t figure out how to do it”
Sure they can.  It’s called “Quantivative Easing”.

Astute Observation by lowrydr310
2010-10-21 09:32 AM

Unfortunately it’s not working out the way it’s supposed to. The top 10% are getting the 50% raise. The other 90% are getting salary cuts, no raises, or losing their jobs completely.

Astute Observation by mikeyD
2010-10-21 09:50 AM

Huh?  I am in the top 1% of income yet have not seen a raise in 3 years so that makes me part of “the other 90%”....I think your vision of reality is a bit, lets say…contradictory.

Astute Observation by Gray
2010-10-27 02:26 AM

You must be doing something wrong. Statistics show you’re the seldom exception from the rule. What happened? No bonus for you, or did your specualtions turn out bad?
:D

Astute Observation by Anonymous
2010-10-21 12:30 PM

Monetary policy works with a lag
Give it five or ten years.

Astute Observation by Renter1
2010-10-21 09:06 AM

$500k for a 2BR??? WTF

Astute Observation by Sue in Irvine
2010-10-21 01:22 PM

Yes, but it has a den wink

Astute Observation by Perspective
2010-10-21 09:16 AM

“...Home price appreciation is not the great deal everyone thinks it is…”

True, but this cuts both ways, no?  Home price depreciation isn’t the horrible thing people think it is. 

If you financed < 2.5x your income to purchase a home and stuck to traditional standards and terms, it’s not too big a deal when you hear that your neigbor’s home sold for 10% less last week.

Unfortunately, the conservative people are being screwed by their profligate neighbors. Always the way…

Astute Observation by Swiller
2010-10-21 10:00 AM

ROFLMFAO!!! Conservatives are heroes. Wait, wait wait, you conservatives voted for all these people into office. Trickle down Theory is in FULL EFFECT!!! That was the god of conservatives…Ronald Reagan. Tax cuts for the RICH have never been better or kinder, yet these rich elite are just over-flowing with compassion to their fellow american by opening business’s in China and other countries that routinely employ human slave labor and degrade humans by denying them simple basic universal rights.

Those conservatives sure are getting screwed! Two conservative wars, backing conservative oil companies, eradicating civil rights based on morals. Yup, those darn conservatives SUFFER under the heavy hand of liberalism.

Astute Observation by no worries
2010-10-21 10:17 AM

Holy Crap Swiller.

I believe she meant “conservative” as the word really means (cautious: avoiding excess), not as a political faction.

Astute Observation by Swiller
2010-10-21 10:36 AM

Yes, sorry about the over-reaction, I’m just tired of all the political signs, comments, news radio’s, talk shows, etc etc. I’m not happy with the LIBERALS either, hence the reason I vote libertarian and not for either of the two major parties.

If I see one more Scott Voight - CONSERVATIVE sign in Lake Forest, I think I’ll get out on vomit on it. Not too mention the fact this bozo is putting signs in places that are illegal

Astute Observation by Perspective
2010-10-21 11:43 AM

Whoa… Yes, I definitely meant conservative “financially” speaking.

After you’re finished ROFLMFAOing, it’s time to take your medication…

Astute Observation by Swiller
2010-10-21 01:21 PM

Unlike most americans, I do not look down on people that require medication for mental issues. Would you mock and make fun of someone who is missing their limbs or colon?

The arrogant attitude and superiority complex of americans, not too mention the pure hypocrisy, is remarkable.

Perhaps to you, people with medical conditions that effect the mind and not the body are inferior to the so called “normal” people. Why?

Astute Observation by Perspective
2010-10-21 02:35 PM

You’re right. We’re all equal. Nobody should be treated differently for any reason whatsoever.

Oh, and we should all earn the same amount of money…

Astute Observation by Anonymous
2010-10-21 05:13 PM

Interesting off topic article today supports Swillers POV

Gene Therapy for Depression May Head to Human Tests (Update1)
http://noir.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601124&sid=ap.toXnsgk8c

Astute Observation by Laura Louzader
2010-10-21 09:03 PM

Thank you for this post.

I have been close to people with crippling mental illness and have watched as a couple of them, very dear people, committed suicide. One of them managed to kill herself piece by piece over a number of years.

Our attitudes toward mental illness are appallingly medieval and punitive.

Severe mental illness seems to be congenital, and there is nothing in the world that blights a person’s life more. You might be able to cope with a serious physical handicap if your brain is intact, but what do you do when your mental hard wiring was hopelessly tangled at birth? This is the case with those who suffer the most crippling forms of mental illness.

It is horrible to see these people, such a small subset of the population, let to be beaten, raped, and starve on the streets while we dispense mucho welfare of every sort to almost every other population in this country. There was a time when these people were at least cared for in a minimal way, but a country bent on subsidizing every middle class indulgence, not to mention supporting a lower class of welfare dependents who are perfectly capable of working, and our Corporate Welfare class, has no money left for these people who truly cannot take care of themselves.

Astute Observation by Gray
2010-10-27 02:29 AM

“Trickle down Theory is in FULL EFFECT!!!”
Only that UP is the new DOWN!
:D

Astute Observation by Anonymous
2010-10-21 12:28 PM

Interestingly, the whole foreclosure HELOC mess doesn’t seem to have hurt the IUSD scores at all - in fact they went up. Higher than Palos Verdes now.

IUSD posts an API score of 916, moves to the top of the list of state’s large school districts
http://newsflash.iusd.org/2010/09/iusd-posts-an-api-score-of-916-moves-to-the-top-of-the-list-of-states-large-school-districts/

If you look at the other top district (San Ramon Valley Unified near San Francisco) in Redfin, the house prices look just as elevated as Irvine
http://www.redfin.com/search#!lat=37.81265702510516&long=-121.99171140511459&market=sanfrancisco&region_id=39176&region_type=2&sf=1,2&uipt=3,2,1&v=6&zoomLevel=15

I guess you get what you pay for.

Astute Observation by FreedomCM
2010-10-21 01:03 PM

I’m still, after all these years, unbelieving that anyone can think the “way below comp” price of $500k for this 2br with dirty carpets and pergo, where you don’t own the land individually, is a deal.


If you make $100k, you are probably taking home $5k/month.  Then you pay your $2800 plus a $200 hoa/month (that may go up as more co-residents default) for the privilege of going up and down three flights?

its going to be irrational longer than I care to wait.

Astute Observation by AZDavidPhx
2010-10-21 03:25 PM

You are assuming a single income household. The way these folks stretch it is by having two people slave away to pay for it and gamble that the next 30 years will be bigger than the present.

Astute Observation by Ren
2010-10-21 03:10 PM

The typical “blame the homeowner” BS that the banks are pushing and you spout in your post ignores the fact that a significant number of people who have been foreclosed on have been victims of outright fraud from the banks.

See http://www.cleveland.com/business/index.ssf/2010/10/mortgage_foreclosure_uproar_sw.html

The banks have royally f-upped the system in their pursuit of enriching themselves and screwing over the rest of the country.  Not sure how letting them steal property they don’t own will fix the problem.

Astute Observation by gepetoh
2010-10-21 05:47 PM

Those cases are few and far in between, even the article acknowledges that MOST foreclosures are due to payment delinquencies.  To NOT blame the homeowners categorically based on what will likely amount to 1 in several thousand cases would be to grossly misstate where the fault lies.  Fact of the matter is that many parties brought this on themselves, INCLUDING the homeowners.  Blaming them is not BS, to NOT blame them would be.

Astute Observation by Gray
2010-10-27 02:24 AM

The point is to balme BOTH sides. The squatter which live rent free without paying a buck for their mortgages, and the banks who totally screwed up the legal process by engaging in illegal shortcuts, just to save a few bucks. This whole system has to be overhauled, and brought back to the proper proceedings that were in place before deregulation and MERS made a mess of it!

Astute Observation by JDSoCal
2010-10-21 11:18 PM

What a dopey claim. 99.99% of these people were properly defaulted on. Stop with the inductive, anecdotal onsense.

Astute Observation by phil
2010-10-21 04:33 PM

“The owners refinanced their first mortgage for $562,500 on 6/15/2007. They only took out $6,500 which probably covered their origination fees plus gave them a few dollars. The refinance cost them their non-recourse protections. When the bank finally disposes of the REO, they may go after this couple for the shortfall. The previous owners already lost $139,000 and their good credit, and later the bank may come back for another pound of flesh.”

I thought the one-action rule would still protect these people despite losing the purchase money protection?

Astute Observation by Jerry
2010-10-21 04:38 PM

Irvine renter,


how do you expect the price in 2011, 2012,2013 and so on?

I saw your prediction was pretty close in 2007. As everyone talking about inflation, will that make the home price much higher if we have 10% inflation per year?

Astute Observation by ozajh
2010-10-21 11:20 PM

“When some of these properties close, the comps are going to be crushed”

But are these sales going to be included in the comps??

(I have heard on various blogs that more and more categories of forced sales are being excluded from the calculations.)

Astute Observation by JDSoCal
2010-10-21 11:21 PM

Irvine Renter, I want to e-mail you something, but can’t view your profile. Got an addy?

Astute Observation by theyenguy
2010-10-22 05:57 PM

Tyler Durden reports news in the linked Zero Hedge article that Fitch Places Bank Of America, All US Banks On Rating Watch Negative. 

I believe that the Financial Regulator, that is the Secretary of the US Treasury, as having broad discretionary authority under the Dodd-Frank Legislation, will one day soon, call for leasing of REO and shadow inventory properties as a solution to the large number of people living payment free in mortgaged property, and as a banking quagmire and deflationary economic collapse emerges.

Furthermore, I see the day coming very soon where a liquidity crisis will occur in the stock and bond markets, and then soon thereafter the US Government will be the sole provider of credit to America; and that credit will be primarily for the strategic needs of the North American Governments, including Canada and Mexico.

Astute Observation by Gray
2010-10-27 02:20 AM

“All the nonsense about improper foreclosures seems to miss one basic point: the people being foreclosed on are not paying their mortgage.”

No, imho the basic point is that only the REAL owner of the mortgage has the legal right to foreclosure! Those banks who fraudulently foreclosure homes STEAL the property from the real owners. There’s no way to ethically defend this. That some house owners now exploit the illegal shortcuts taken by the banks as a way for delaying their eviction even longer is morally questionable, too, of course. But this still doesn’t justify the behaviour of the banks. There are lots of crooks on both sides, that’s the issue. And who’s gonna tell which side has the more dirty hands?

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.

<< Back to main