Just in Time

Oct 3rd, 2008  
by IrvineRenter  in HELOC Abuse

Astute Observations

Astute Observation by Allison C.
2008-10-03 06:41 AM

Cute cartoon. I wonder if the treats will be less for the trick or treaters this year. My neighbor is planning to turn off all the lights and not giving out any candies.

Astute Observation by lawyerliz
2008-10-03 06:59 AM

Just curious, what percentage of people can now afford the median house, vs at peak?

Sorry I haven’t been here much, but I have been glued to Calculated Risk.

I’d buy this at 20% more off.  Nice house.

Astute Observation by alan
2008-10-03 07:49 AM

? Nice house ????

Only two pics of the house, nothing special, typical stucco box design, ugly from the outside if you ask me.  Small yard turned into a brick patio.  At least landscaping is not much work but no garden and very small front lawn to mow.  If they used the heloc money it doesn’t look like they spent it on the house unless it was bricking the back yard.

Astute Observation by SnowKat
2008-10-03 09:09 AM

I agree alan, this house looks like it hasn’t been updated since the early 90’s with the white wash wood & white tile in the kitcken.  I wouldn’t say it’s ‘ugly’ though… Maybe just not my style.

I am guessing that there are not very many pictures because they are as unimpressive as the kitchen/family room shots.

I miss houses that have lawns ... smirk

Astute Observation by Joe Irvine
2008-10-03 10:27 AM

I agree. Nice house.

Astute Observation by freedomCM
2008-10-03 11:45 AM

eh…no back yard, and right next to a huge apartment complex.  no updates in 20 years.

why should this be worth more than it was purchased for?

Astute Observation by h
2008-10-03 03:30 PM

Inflation?

Astute Observation by Larrygg
2008-10-03 08:09 AM

Another fool living in the past. This house will probably sell for $450K in the next few years. I’m curious what steps the lenders are taking to secure their paper? 20% down at a minimum and I’d venture to say that whatever appraisal they get,cut that number by 25%. If they were smart. There’s no way that an appraisal would come it at anywhere near $670K. Maybe last year but not this year.

Astute Observation by Mr.Mortgage
2008-10-03 08:38 AM

We just posted one the most comprehensive slideshows on the meltdown we have seen to date.
http://thegreatloanblog.blogspot.com

Astute Observation by WaitingToBuyByAndBy
2008-10-03 12:40 PM

Very nice.

Astute Observation by AZDavidPhx
2008-10-03 08:43 AM

Astute Observation by IrvineRenter
2008-10-03 08:47 AM

LOL! Another classic.

Astute Observation by SnowKat
2008-10-03 09:12 AM

LOL  Good one !

Astute Observation by Walter
2008-10-03 08:47 AM

Think I will take the kids to Balboa Island for trick or treating. From what I understand it is the strongest RE market around so we don’t expect to find many brown lawns.

Astute Observation by DeadBeatRenter
2008-10-03 09:28 PM

No lawns on the island….Every inch is concrete or stucco!

Astute Observation by NY-interest
2008-10-03 08:50 AM

I wonder if all this deleveraging will fully shake out the real from the fake in Southern CA. 

My wife’s originally from Irvine, and I love the area. My biggest con with Southern CA is the people.  I never felt that they were real.  I guess with their houses being used as ATMs, my gut feeling was correct in that it was not real wealth.

Perhaps with people actually having to legitimately earn a salary to pay for an extravagant lifestyle, a true soul and culture may return to the area.

Astute Observation by IrvineRenter
2008-10-03 08:59 AM

“Perhaps with people actually having to legitimately earn a salary to pay for an extravagant lifestyle, a true soul and culture may return to the area. “

We can all dare to dream…

I hope you are correct.

Astute Observation by SnowKat
2008-10-03 09:15 AM

NY - Any person I have met in OC that I could ‘gel’ with was NOT from here (for the most part)... LoL Go figure!

Astute Observation by Hormiguero
2008-10-03 10:10 AM

Southern california has always been driven by real estate booms and busts, going back to 1860s LA.

Irvine is nothing if not one giant movie set, scientifically designed to be the perfect suburban image.

Do you really expect to find something besides actors under the lights on a sound stage?

Astute Observation by CK
2008-10-03 11:01 AM

Ah, my favorite subject on IHB.  Dickheads from somewhere else saying that everybody who lives in Irvine is without soul, culture, morals, and now are apparentely fake actors.  Everything these experts know about residents of Irvine was learned by watching an episode of “The OC”.  It’s even more fun to see that stereotype furthered by the moderator.

I wish that somehow when these experts posted that their own zip code would pop up in the corner of the post, so we could give it the appropriate context.  I’m sure we could have a lot of fun slicing and dicing their neighborhoods.  So on that note, where do you live, homeyguru?  What makes your people better than the actors in Irvine?

Astute Observation by Senator Larry Craig
2008-10-03 12:49 PM

Certainly, there is a significant measure of truth to the stereotype.  I lived in Irvine for 15 years, leaving in 2004. It does indeed lack soul and culture, if only in a relative sense.  It is not fair to generalize, but the plastic faces and chests perusing the sculptured setting in SUV’s with rims and trims of gold is prolific.  Since leaving, I have redifined what the word “community” means to me.  O.C. and Irvine offers great weather in which to be hopelessly confined to a rat race.  I suppose one cannot possible understand the nonsense of it all from the perspective of inside the cheese maze.

Astute Observation by CK
2008-10-03 01:50 PM

IMO, if you can’t find a community in Irvine, you are not looking very hard. And by no means am I saying Irvine has a better community than anywhere else—- every place has its merits. It’s just that to say that Irvine has no community because you didn’t get involved or like the community is very disengenous.

BTW—I travel a lot with work.  I have been to every major city in the US.  Irvine by no means has the corner on the plastic surgery or gaudy vehicle market.  And don’t forget that Irvine does not equal Newport Beach, my friend.  Don’t lump us in with our neighbors.  I would not live around those a-holes either.  But I do like their beaches.

Astute Observation by SnowKat
2008-10-03 02:11 PM

CK - I think what they are trying to say is that, for the most part, Irvinites keep to themselves… Pull their cars into their garages & close the door behind themselves.  I don’t think that their morals, culture, or souls are in question.

Astute Observation by NY-interest
2008-10-03 05:16 PM

CK,

I was born and raised in zip code 10710.  So you can slice and dice my background whatever way you’d like. Please save your “dickhead” comments to yourself.

My wife, who was born and raised in University Park, and I both come from middle class families.  I’m not preaching from atop any soapbox.  I’m just calling it as I see it in regards to the lack of soul/culture that exists in the Irvine/LA area.

My wife’s parents grew up in small towns on the east coast and ultimately settled on the west coast.  Funny how both her parents, my wife and I have drawn the same conclusions about Irvine.  It’s a lovely area, an area where I may ultimately settle, but it lacks soul and culture.

Astute Observation by idrnkurmlkshk
2008-10-03 06:06 PM

It’s a generalization CK.  But from the sound of your defensive, snotty response it sure reinforces the point.

Astute Observation by SnowKat
2008-10-03 02:19 PM

“Irvine is nothing if not one giant movie set, scientifically designed to be the perfect suburban image.”

A giant movie set ?? LoL LOL

Sounds a little like jealousy to me.

Astute Observation by MandarinoMiracoloso
2008-10-04 12:21 AM

So much dumb money was “withdrawn” and spent in Irvine because so much was made available.  Create instant riches, and many people will waste it.  It does not matter where it happens, people will tend to act the same.  IMHO

Astute Observation by phil
2008-10-03 08:56 AM

I have asked this before but never received an answer.  Someone has to know how many loans in Irvine or at least Orange County are Option ARMs?

This would really help gauge how large a tidal wave we have coming.

Anyone?

Astute Observation by IrvineRenter
2008-10-03 09:23 AM

I don’t know of any database that has these statistics. I do know that 32% of all loan originations (purchases and refinances) in 2006 were Option ARMs, and 80% of all originations in 2005 and 2006 were either Option ARMs or interest-only ARMs. There was a lot of refinancing going on during this time period. This problem is huge.

Astute Observation by freedomCM
2008-10-03 11:52 AM

IR

80% of originations (where?)  OC?  Irvine?  CA?

Astute Observation by IrvineRenter
2008-10-03 02:02 PM

In all of California more than 80% of loan originations in 2006 were either Option ARM or interest-only.

Astute Observation by AZDavidPhx
2008-10-03 06:48 PM

California is broke from all of the borrowing.  Your governor is asking the rest of the country to help out and come to the rescue.  I think this is going to be the end of some of the people on here crowing that people not from the area have no business coming on to this blog and talk about a place that they do not live in.

Astute Observation by oc_analyst
2008-10-03 09:04 AM

This house has an un-fixable negative in that it sides to a cheap condo development.  I used to live on Eastmont in the not-as-cheap townhomes across the street from the flats next to this house.  While Woodbridge is arguably the best value in Irvine (no Mello-Roos, $73/month association for 12 pools and 48 tennis courts, etc.), it will be a tough sell. 

Rent would be about $2,900. 
Ownership economic cost would be $3,229.* 
Rent-saver breakeven price: $597,000.*

My projection: more to fall.  At market bottoms, even good areas get to or below rent saver pricing.  Given higher credit standards, and the risk associated with the underlying asset, one could argue that rent-savers will not opt to finance a house until economic cost is well below equivalent rent.

*Assumes 30 year fixed, 6.5% rate, 20% down, 6.5% cost of capital, $100/mo in R&M, $73/mo assoc., $70 prop. insurance, 1% property tax, 28% federal, 9.3% CA tax brackets, that buyer has enough income to where mortgage interest deduction is fully incremental in said brackets, and excludes mortgage principal as this is not an economic cost but a transfer from one asset (cash) to another (home equity).  R&M may be a hair low, but it’s a recession: you should learn to do more yourself!

Astute Observation by IrvineRenter
2008-10-03 09:26 AM

That would be a GRM of 205. That is too high.

Astute Observation by Beinformed
2008-10-03 09:42 AM

Again, this home is overprice, if you apply Whitney’s formula.  If back in 1996 the house sold for $275,000, and if I recall, that was the high selling point, then you add 4% yearly and you get around $446,000 for present price.  Plus factor in that it is a buyers market and we have yet to hit bottom. If it sells for around $400,00, I will be surprised, R.E. investments compared to stock market investments returns only around 4% yearly, whereas stock market returns have historically given around 10% returns.  If they seller gets around $400,000 then he should take the money and run.

Astute Observation by billinny
2008-10-03 10:13 AM

“Most of the cases of HELOC abuse I profile here are the extreme ones, but nearly every property I look at has some amount of mortgage equity withdrawal.”

I’m curious if the ratio of ‘extreme HELOC abuse” to “properties on market” is rising or falling…appreciating this will be more anectodotal in nature.  In other words IR have you found you have been needed to look at more, or fewer, properties on the market to find the mroe extreme examples of HELOC abuse.

My thinking is that the worst abusers will be the first to be forced sellers, thus would be a high portion of the houses on the market.  So, in theory over time we will see fewer of the very severe cases as the worst ones were the first wave of forced sellers.  To the extent there were some with less abuse, it seems these people may be less likely to become forced sellers and can ride the market out.

Astute Observation by houseonlegs
2008-10-03 11:01 AM

You also have to consider a lot of the extreme abusers were still refinancing in 06 and 07 and their arms/option arms have not reset yet. I think people that took max cash out wont even put their home on the market, they have already given up. They will make their minimun payment until their loan resets and then they will just wait to be kicked out.

Astute Observation by BHC
2008-10-03 01:50 PM

the funniest thing is, everyone posting on this blog are going to be helping these and other Irvinites finance/payoff their huge amount of debt.  Who really is laughing now?

Astute Observation by SnowKat
2008-10-03 02:24 PM

Laugh it up!  We will be laughing when they through you out of your McMansion wink Hopefully you saved some HELOC for a rainy day…

Astute Observation by Schadendude
2008-10-03 02:58 PM

Ya including you f*cktard…  Least we get to keep our credit rating.  Good luck buying in again once the sheriff comes to throw you out.

Astute Observation by Richard
2008-10-03 04:04 PM

Uh…the market tanked after the bill was passed.

Astute Observation by occasionalreader
2008-10-03 05:10 PM

Anybody familiar with the case of the woman heloc-ed to death?

http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/10/03/eviction.suicide.attempt/index.html

Astute Observation by lawyerliz
2008-10-03 06:25 PM

Grrrr.  I made a long post and didn’t notice I was supposed to write the word in and it got deleted. 

Bottom line is that I’m not buying back into the mkt for a while, and when I sold last fall, vowed I wouldn’t get back in intil it went below 10000 and now I’m thinking maybe less than that.

I’m beginning to see a bottom in South Fla, and it’s a really low bottom.

Astute Observation by lawyerliz
2008-10-03 06:29 PM

After reading IHB for a long time, I expect there to be no lawn.

I wouldn’t pay more than 300k, maybe 275 in South Florida for the house.

And of course, I have no idea what the surroundings are.

Astute Observation by mallen
2008-10-03 06:37 PM

Fannie Mae forgives loan for woman who shot herself

http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/10/03/eviction.suicide.attempt/index.html

Astute Observation by ochomehunter
2008-10-03 07:32 PM

MUST WATCH VIDEO!!!!!!! Bush - a crying wolf!
http://www.thedailyshow.com/video/index.jhtml?videoId=186052&title=Clusterf#@k-to-the-Poor-House—-Dive-of-Death

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.

<< Back to main